Reasonably Practicable?

admin • March 25, 2025

The Victorian Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 requires that the employer has a duty to ensure a healthy and safe workplace. This duty must be met as far as reasonably practicable.


But what does this actually mean?


The following must be considered when determining what is reasonably practicable: (according to section 20(2) of The Act):

(a)  The likelihood the hazard or risk concerned eventuating;

(b)  The degree of harm that would result if the hazard eventuated;

(c)  What the person concerned knows, or ought to reasonably know, about the hazard or risk;

(d)  The availability and suitability of ways to eliminate or reduce the hazard or risk;

(e)  The cost of eliminating or reducing the hazard or risk.


This is often an area of confusion – primarily because the test for what is ‘reasonably practicable’ is in fact objective. When we consider this, it is best to look to WorkSafe for guidance.


WorkSafe Victoria provides some clarification in their Position Statement on the matter:

‘a person is to be judged by the standard of behaviour expected of a reasonable person in the duty-holder’s position who is required to comply with the same duty and is:

• Committed to providing the highest level of protection for people against risks to their health and safety.

• Proactive in taking measures to protect the health and safety of people.’

-         WorkSafe position statement - reasonably practicable

 

There must be a weighing up of each of the 5 points listed under section 20(2) of The Act (above), but with a clear presumption in favour of safety. This means that the likelihood of harm occurring, and the seriousness of the potential outcome, must be the most important factor. The cost must be considered to be the least important factor when deciding what is reasonably practicable.


‘If the degree of harm is significant, e.g. death or serious injury is highly likely, then it is extremely unlikely that the cost of eliminating or reducing the risk would ever be so disproportionate to the risk to justify a decision not to implement an available and suitable control measure.’

-          WorkSafe position statement - reasonably practicable

 

When considering what the person concerned should reasonably know about eliminating the hazard, the state of knowledge regarding hazards and controls must be considered and this must be applied in line with the ranking under the hierarchy of control.


The definition of what is ‘reasonably practicable’ is often one which causes some contention. It is important to go back to the WorkSafe position statement to make sure that you are making decisions in line with the intentions of The Act. Of course, it is always required that the highest level of protection from a hazard is provided in order to ensure a safe workplace.


To read more about this:

How WorkSafe applies the law in relation to Reasonably Practicable | WorkSafe Victoria

Failure to report a notifiable incident is an offence

By admin • May 20, 2025
Section 38 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 imposes a legal duty on employers to notify of incidents: "An employer or self-employed person must not, without reasonable excuse, fail to notify the Authority immediately after becoming aware that an incident has occurred at a workplace under the management and control of the employer or self-employed person. s38(1) The employer must notify immediately by calling WorkSafe by calling 13 23 60, at which time they will be given a reference number. Thie reference number serves as proof that the employer did immediately notify the regulator." s38 The employer must fill out an incident notification form (found at Incident notification form | WorkSafe Victoria ) and this form must be submitted within 48 hours of the incident occurring. Failure to notify is a breach of legal duty and the offence can result in prosecution. It is also a legal duty for the employer to preserve the site of the incident. Failure to preserve the scene is an indictable offence under section 39 of the OHS Act. So, what classifies as a notifiable incident? Any of the following: 1. Death 2. Exposure to a substance resulting in a need for medical treatment within 48 hours 3. Any incident resulting in the need for immediate in-patient hospital treatment 4. Any incident result in the need for immediate medical treatment for any of the injuries listed: a. Amputation b. Serious head injury c. Serious eye injury d. Removal of skin (eg: scalping, degloving) e. Electric shock f. Spinal injury g. Loss of bodily function h. Serious lacerations (ie: requiring stitching or other medical treatment) 5. Any incident through which a person is at serious risk as a result of exposure to an: a. Uncontrolled escape, spillage, or leakage of a substance b. Implosion, explosion or fire c. Electric shock d. Fall or release from height of any plant, substance or thing e. Incident involving plant (collapse, overturning, failure or malfunction) as per OHS Regulations f. Collapse or failure of an excavation or mine (or of any shoring support) g. In-rush of water, mud or gas into an excavation, tunnel or mine h. Interruption of ventilation in a mine, excavation or tunnel i. Any incident involving dangerous goods or explosives WorkSafe has a straightforward guide on the process here: Report an incident | WorkSafe Victoria Don’t forget that as Health and Safety representative, you have the right to access information in relation to incidents which affect your DWG. For more information on this topic, take a look at previous articles relating to relating to HSR’s entitlements to access information: HSR Training & Workplace Safety | BeSafe | Reg. Vic. For more detail on this, visit Obligations of an employer to health and safety representatives | WorkSafe Victoria As always, you are welcome to get in touch with us for a chat HSR Training and support | BeSafe | Regional Victoria

Young workers are vulnerable

By admin • May 13, 2025
Young workers are at among the most vulnerable in the workplace. They are at an increased risk of injury or death at work. There are a number of factors which contribute to this, including: Being new to their job or industry Not knowing what their OHS rights are Not having OHS training Not being supervised sufficiently Have less experience in their role Feeling afraid to speak up about safety issues Not knowing how to report safety issues Being under pressure by other workers or their employer Insecure work Employers have a duty to provide a safe workplace to their employees, and particular care should be taken to ensure the safety of the young and vulnerable workers. Read more about this at Young workers: Safety basics | WorkSafe Victoria . When a young worker is killed at work, the ramifications are devastating. In these videos, two brave fathers describe what happened when their sons went to work and never came home: Workplace Incidents Consultative Committee: David Brownlee's story | dtf.vic.gov.au Workplace Incidents Consultative Committee: Brett Struhs' story | dtf.vic.gov.au Both companies were charged following the deaths of these young men, but nothing will bring them back to their families.  Both stories highlight the importance of protecting young workers from hazards in the workplace, as is the duty of the employer.