$125,000 Fine After Workers Fall

admin • October 15, 2024

Valmont (Vic) Pty Ltd was sentenced in the Sunshine Magistrates' Court on Thursday 3 October after earlier being found guilty of one charge of failing to provide and maintain a safe system of work and one charge of failing to ensure a workplace under its management or control was safe and without risks to health.

Valmont was fined without a conviction and mandated to pay $42,752 in costs. The company had been assigned to transform level two of a multistorey car park on Clarke Street in Sunshine into office space. The project entailed the removal of a car park ramp between levels one and two, the installation of structural steel and formwork, and the pouring of concrete into the void to finalize the office floor. In July 2019, a segment of the formwork collapsed when a steel beam connecting it to the existing slab detached as the concrete was being poured, resulting in three workers plummeting more than two metres to the level below. Two workers were hospitalized with serious injuries. A WorkSafe inquiry revealed that Valmont had failed to arrange for a building surveyor or engineer to inspect the formwork prior to the concrete pour. The court concluded that it would have been reasonably practicable for Valmont to have organized a pre-pour inspection and to have secured a written inspection report affirming that the formwork was structurally sound to bear the concrete pour.

WorkSafe Executive Director of Health and Safety Sam Jenkin said working with formwork could be high risk and there was no excuse for omitting important safety processes.

"Having a competent person inspect formwork before a concrete pour begins is a crucial step designed to avoid exactly this kind of disastrous scenario," Mr Jenkin said.

"In this case two workers were injured and it could very easily have been much, much worse."

To prevent falls when working with formwork employers should:

Ensure a competent person produces a formwork design capable of supporting the expected dynamic and static loads.
Have systems in place to formally sign off a formwork deck as structurally sound, complete and safe for other trade workers to use as a work platform.
Provide employees undertaking construction work with site specific training, including the onsite risks associated with formwork decks.
Ensure High Risk Construction Work is not performed unless a Safe Work Method Statement is prepared and followed.
Use a fall arrest system, such as a catch platform or safety nets.

For more information visit: https://www.worksafe.vic.gov.au/news/2024-10/125000-fine-after-workers-fall-concrete-formwork-collapse

< Older Post

Newer Post >

Is workplace safety a social justice issue?

By admin • February 11, 2025

Is Work Safety a Social Justice Issue? The 20 th February has been named The World Day for Social Justice. But is Work Safety a Social Justice Issue? When certain groups face disproportionate risks due to factors like systemic inequalities, unsafe working conditions become a social justice concern. For example, certain demographics (such as racial minorities or low-income workers) often experience higher rates of workplace injuries and illnesses due to systemic disadvantages. Poor work safety practices can lead to significant health disparities, further emphasizing the social justice aspect. Unequal power dynamics between employers and employees can prevent workers from raising concerns about safety issues, perpetuating unsafe conditions. The right to a safe workplace is a fundamental human right – but not all workers are treated equitably in the protection of their health and wellbeing. To read more about the World Day For Social Justice, visit World Day of Social Justice | United Nations

Heatwaves as a work hazard.

By admin • February 4, 2025

When there is a heatwave, it can introduce temperatures which are a new hazard not normally experienced in a workplace. As always, the employer must eliminate or minimise risks as far as reasonably practicable. That means that when conditions change, it’s time to do a risk assessment and put new controls in place. There is no single ‘stop work’ temperature. Various factors need to be taken into account which include humidity, air flow and the type of work being performed. Heatwave conditions create a work-related risk in the form of heat stress and fatigue. But there are various ways to control the risk. Things to consider may include: working in the cooler part of the day moving work to a different location limiting tasks which require higher physical effort during the hotter period changing work expectations and allowing workers to self-pace their work ensuring access to cool water - and rehydration electrolytes if required providing shade air conditioning or fans if possible ensuring workers are not working in isolation ensuring supervision is in place taking into account more vulnerable workers - for example those who may be young, pregnant, suffer an illness, etc training workers to ensure they understand the risk and how to recognise symptoms ensure first aid and medical assistance is available Remember that the risk posed by heat is not just limited to outdoor workers. Indoor workers can be exposed to unsafe working conditions too - including high temperatures, thermal radiation and humidity. As with all hazards - when considering what control to put in place, the usual hierarchy of control should be used – with elimination being considered first. If this can’t be done, then consider substitution, followed by isolation/ engineering controls, then administrative controls and finally PPE as the last option. As always, the effectiveness of the controls should be monitored and reviewed. Health and Safety Representatives (HSRs)s can be proactive in this area by consulting with the employer and attempting to resolve the risk. If there is an immediate risk to health and safety, then they can direct a cease work. HSRs play an important role in ensuring a safe workplace – and this includes during heatwave conditions.